| Local Title and Year |
Name |
Hometown |
MAOT Placement |
| 2005 - Blackhawk Valley OT |
Kathryn Strause |
Rock Island |
|
| 2006 - Miss John A Logan OT |
Campbell Hunt |
Marion |
|
| 2007 - Miss Greater Woodfield OT |
Merriebeth Cox |
Roselle |
Talent and Evening Gown Preliminary Awards at MAOTeen; Miss Indiana 2012 |
| 2008 - Miss Metropolis OT |
Emily Travis |
Metropolis |
|
| 2009 - Miss Dupage County OT |
Andrea Novak |
Arlington Heights |
Troy Univeristy MAOTeen Scholarship |
| 2010 - Miss Blackhawk Valley OT |
Kaitlyn Wehr |
Moline |
|
| 2011 - Miss Southern Illinois OT |
Summer Robbins |
Hillsboro |
Preliminary Evening Gown Award at MAOTeen |
| 2012 - Miss Central Illinois OT |
Grace Khachaturian |
Champaign |
|
| 2013 - Miss Northern Suburbs OT |
Isabelle Hanson |
Glen Ellyn |
Dr. Glenn Harman Instrumental Scholarship Award at MAOTeen |
| 2014 - Miss Windy City OT |
Grace Etzkorn |
Lisle |
|
| 2015 - Miss Windy City OT |
Peyton Tucker |
Moline |
|
| 2016 - Miss Southern IL OT |
Christine Bryant |
Marion |
|
